5 Comments
User's avatar
Bill Kirchner's avatar

For an interesting comparison, check out "Jim Hall and Bob Brookmeyer: Live at the North Sea Jazz Festival 1979."

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bZ_jEMSbfvo

Christian Muermann's avatar

You’ve written a great piece about Michel Petrucciani here, Marc 👍. Unfortunately, I never saw him live, though I did catch a few of his concerts on TV and own four of his CDs. But not "Power Of Three". However, I just listened to it on YouTube. "In A Sentimental Mood" with Jim Hall, is absolutely fantastic.

https://youtu.be/QYOIBB0UBFw?is=XiRKeBMH-xUiJXrE

He left behind so much music that one might think he lived to be 50 or 60, yet he was only 36 when he left us 😔.

George McFetridge's avatar

Shorter sounds like he's making up for lost Weather Report time with not much emotional involvement here. Not the first player to use a gig as a practise session.

Barbara Brighton's avatar

I had the honor of seeing him perform a few times at the old Catalina's. Each time his struggle to get on the piano bench was painful to witness. Michel's playing was gorgeous and moving. The profound experience I had was looking at this man whose body was twisted and yet his hands were perfect. I was completely struck when I saw his hands close up. They were absolutely flawless. It made this non-believer question this miracle. I still think about it.

Carl Woideck's avatar

Inspired by Bill, here's another comparison, Bob Brookmeyer and Ted Rosenthal:

https://youtu.be/OC8cxjMOygM?is=RZBY9eizNDx6xsgU

If you scroll down there are quite a few more selections from the CD, including a great "Night and Day", below:

https://youtu.be/BRTnPw5bSsU?si=7j9IDBG1-qnoPEDD